|
Earlier this year, news about vitamin E
research hit the press and caused some confusion.
The report referred to a meta-analysis
of 19 studies, which individually did not find
any
concerns with vitamin E. These studies were selected
from 2,170 studies on
vitamin E, and the authors of the
meta-analysis concluded that high-dose vitamin E,
greater than 400 IU per day, may result in a small
increase in deaths - from different
causes - in elderly
patients with chronic diseases.
The authors themselves found flaws in
their analysis: The small size of the majority of
the
studies in the meta-analysis; the inclusion of patients
with chronic diseases
(which limits the relevance of the
data for healthy adults); the concurrent use of other
vitamins in the studies; and the inconsistent use of
different forms of vitamin E,
particularly the synthetic
form.
The benefits of vitamin E, found in
many of the trials, were not discussed. In the
Cambridge
Heart and Antioxidant Study, vitamin E was actually
found to reduce
heart attacks by 70-77 percent. This was
one of the three larger studies included
in the
meta-analysis and included 2,002 people.
Even more impressive information was
found in the MRC/BHF Heart Protection Study
of 20,536
high-risk individuals using synthetic vitamin E, vitamin
C and beta carotene.
This study identified no reductions
or increases in heart attacks, strokes, cancers or
other
major adverse events in five years.
One study, using combined "high-dose"
antioxidants, showed a 34 percent reduction
in
age-related macular degeneration without any significant
side effects.
It is important to remember there are
numerous studies, not included in the meta-analysis,
showing no significant increases in cardiac or other
mortality with doses of vitamin E up
to 800 IU per day.
Vitamin E is one of the body's
principle fat-soluble antioxidants. At doses of 1200 IU,
it decreases C-reactive protein, a measurable indicator
of inflammation in our blood.
Recent studies show
vitamin E decreases inflammation in patients with
rheumatoid
arthritis and allergies by reducing
substances that initiate inflammation and excessive
immune system responses.
Research always reveals conflicting
data. There were literally hundreds of responses to
the
authors' analysis, questioning the interpretation of the
information. They again
concluded that vitamin E at 400 IU per day is a safe dose for most healthy adults.
This will probably continue to be a
hot topic debated in coming years, as research
reveals
more data on which to base recommendations.
In the meantime, it's probably best to
be conservative: Use vitamin E in its natural forms
and
do not exceed 400 IU per day. |